Bookshelf or floorstanding? Speakers sized to your room

|Theo Lindqvist
Bowers & Wilkins 702 S3: pair flanking a fireplace in a pale Georgian room

The question sounds like one of size and budget: small speakers or big ones? In practice it is a question about your room. The same pair of speakers can sound full and effortless in one space and thin, or boomy, in another, and the room usually decides which before the speakers do.

Here is how the two types differ, what the room does to bass, and how to choose a size that suits the space you actually have.

What really separates the two

A bookshelf speaker, or standmount, is usually a compact two-way design: a tweeter for the treble and a single bass/midrange driver for everything else, in a cabinet small enough to sit on a stand or a sturdy piece of furniture. A floorstanding speaker uses a tall cabinet with more internal volume and, usually, more driver area for bass.

The practical difference is bass. To reproduce low notes at a given volume, a speaker has to move a lot of air, which takes larger cones, more of them, or more cabinet volume. A small speaker can play surprisingly deep, but it reaches its limits sooner as you turn it up.

Many floorstanders are also three-way designs, giving the midrange its own driver. The Bowers & Wilkins 702 S3 is a good example: a 25 mm carbon dome tweeter on top of the cabinet, a dedicated 150 mm Continuum midrange, and three 165 mm Aerofoil bass units below. Because the midrange driver is spared the large movements that bass demands, voices and instruments can stay clean even when the music is big.

Why the room matters more than the cabinet

Every room has resonances, called room modes, set by its dimensions. At certain bass frequencies the sound reinforces itself between parallel walls, and at others it cancels. In a small room these modes are spaced widely and are easy to excite, so a speaker with a lot of deep bass can sound boomy and uneven.

That is why "bigger is better" breaks down. In a compact room, a good bookshelf speaker often sounds more balanced than a floorstander, because it is not pumping energy into frequencies the room cannot handle. In a large or open-plan space, the reverse is true: small speakers can sound lightweight, and a floorstander fills the volume without strain.

Kanto TUK (Gen 2): walnut pair styled on a pale living-room sideboard
Photograph: Kanto, Manufacturer press image (product sold by SIGNAL), via Wikimedia Commons

Bookshelf speakers: precision in a small footprint

Bookshelf speakers suit studies, bedrooms, smaller living rooms and desks. Their small front baffles also help them disappear, leaving a well-focused stereo image between them.

The Bowers & Wilkins 607 S3 pairs a titanium dome tweeter with a 130 mm Continuum cone, and Bowers & Wilkins designed it for smaller spaces. The Sonus faber Lumina II is a two-way shelf speaker with a 29 mm soft dome tweeter and a 150 mm cone driver, and Sonus faber says the Lumina range's port design makes the speakers significantly less sensitive to placement, even close to a back wall.

One caveat about the name: a "bookshelf" speaker rarely sounds its best inside a bookshelf. Pushed into a cavity, the bass becomes thick and the image collapses. Proper stands that put the tweeter near seated ear height make a striking difference, and our speaker placement guide explains why.

Floorstanders: scale and ease

Floorstanders suit medium to large rooms, open-plan spaces and listeners who play orchestral, organ or electronic music at realistic levels. They also need no stands, so their footprint is often not much larger than a bookshelf speaker on a stand.

Not every floorstander is a three-way. The Sonus faber Maxima Amator is a two-way floorstanding design with a 28 mm soft dome tweeter and a 180 mm midwoofer, in a solid walnut cabinet with Saint Laurent marble and brass. It is a reminder that a tall cabinet can be about refinement as much as power.

If you want to skip separate electronics altogether, active speakers build the amplifiers in. The Bang & Olufsen Beolab 8 is a compact three-way pair with 300 W of class D amplification in each speaker, Active Room Compensation to adapt to where you place it, and Wi-Fi streaming over AirPlay 2 and Google Cast.

KEF LS60 Wireless: royal blue pair in a bright dining room
Photograph: KEF, Manufacturer press image (product sold by SIGNAL), via Wikimedia Commons

The third option: bookshelf speakers plus a subwoofer

A subwoofer separates the two jobs. Your main speakers handle the music you locate in space, and the sub handles the lowest bass, which is hard to locate by ear. Because the sub can be positioned for the best bass independently of the speakers, a 2.1 system often gives smoother low end in a difficult room than a pair of floorstanders.

The KEF KC62 is a compact subwoofer with two 6.5-inch drivers in a force-cancelling design. It offers five room placement EQ presets, including wall, corner, cabinet and an apartment mode, and a line output with a high-pass filter, so you can stop your bookshelf speakers from straining at the deepest notes.

A quick guide by room

Your room Our usual starting point
Desk, study or bedroom Bookshelf speakers on stands or a solid surface
Small living room, speakers near the back wall Bookshelf speakers designed to tolerate wall proximity
Medium living room Either; let your music and the space between the speakers decide
Large or open-plan space Floorstanders, or bookshelf speakers with a subwoofer
Awkward room with boomy spots Bookshelf speakers plus a subwoofer, placed for the room
A pair of walnut-fronted Sonus faber Lumina II bookshelf speakers on slim black stands either side of a yellow sofa in a loft living room with a riveted steel door behind
Photograph: Sonus faber, Manufacturer press image (product sold by SIGNAL), via Wikimedia Commons

Before you buy

  • Measure the room and note where the speakers and your seat can realistically go.
  • Check your amplifier. Speakers differ in how easy they are to drive; the Maxima Amator, for instance, has a nominal impedance of 4 ohms, so your amplifier should be comfortable with that load. Our hi-fi components include amplifiers to suit.
  • Measure the room first. Note the floor area, the distance to the walls and where you sit; a speaker that suits a large open room can overwhelm a small one.

Browse the full range of hi-fi speakers, and remember that whichever size you choose, placement will shape the result as much as the speakers themselves.

Header photograph: Bowers & Wilkins, Manufacturer press image (product sold by SIGNAL), via Wikimedia Commons.