A voice assistant is the front door to a smart home. It is how most people turn off the lights from the sofa, set a kitchen timer with floury hands, or ask who is at the door. A smart display adds a screen to that conversation, so the answer can be a picture, a camera view or a set of controls.
This autumn has been a busy one, with Apple announcing its first smart display and a new version of Siri. Here is how the main assistants differ, what a display adds, and how to choose the right device for each room.
The three assistants
Most homes end up choosing one of three assistants, and the choice usually follows the phones in the house.
- Siri is Apple's assistant, built around the Apple Home app, iPhone and Apple's speakers, TV box and now its display. Apple's new version, Siri AI, is arriving in beta across its home devices.
- Gemini for Home is Google's assistant for the Google Home platform, and Google's newest speaker is built around it.
- Alexa is Amazon's assistant. It runs on Amazon's Echo speakers and displays, which we do not carry, and it is built into many products from other makers.
All three can control a wide range of smart home devices, and Matter means a growing number of accessories work with any of them. Our guide to Matter, Thread and the new smart home explains how. The bigger differences are in which phone controls them best, which services they connect to, and how they handle privacy.
What a screen adds
A speaker answers you. A display shows you. That matters for a handful of everyday things: seeing who is at the door, checking a camera, glancing at the weather and your calendar, following a recipe step by step, and controlling lights or the thermostat with a tap when you would rather not speak. It also makes a good digital photo frame when you are not using it.
The trade-off is placement. A display needs to be where you can see it, which usually means the kitchen, a hallway or a desk. Bedrooms and living rooms are often better served by a speaker.
Apple HomeView: Apple's first smart display
The Apple HomeView is Apple's first device of its kind. It has a 7-inch Liquid Retina display that Apple says adjusts its brightness from 500 nits all the way down to 0.3 nits, so it can dim right down in a dark room. The tabletop model stands on a domed, color-matched speaker base, and a wall-mounted model is available too, with the mount sold separately.
A few things stand out from Apple's announcement:
- It can recognize up to six household members by face, so each person sees their own information.
- It can show up to nine camera feeds at once and listen for smoke and carbon monoxide alarm sounds.
- The Home app is built in, and Apple says it works with Works with Apple Home and Matter accessories. It also acts as a home hub.
- Apple says its A18 chip processes camera and microphone data separately from the rest of the system.
Siri AI is available on HomeView in beta, in English in a set of countries including the US. Pre-orders opened on October 13, and Apple says HomeView is available from November 13.
Google Nest Hub Max: the kitchen screen
The Google Nest Hub Max has the largest screen here, a 10-inch HD display with stereo speakers and a 3-inch woofer. It has a built-in Nest Cam for video calls with Google Meet and for checking in on home while you are out, with live view and motion and sound alerts on your phone. Its Face Match feature recognizes you and shows your own reminders and calendar, and Ambient EQ adapts the screen to the light in the room so photos look natural. Google also lists it as a Matter hub and a Thread border router.
The speakers
If you do not need a screen, a speaker is the quieter choice, and it often sounds better.
The Google Home Speaker is Google's new speaker, built for Gemini for Home. It is wrapped in a 3D-knitted yarn and glows from underneath when it is listening or speaking. It has three far-field microphones, a hardware switch to mute them, and 360-degree sound. Google says you can pair it with a Google TV Streamer for spatial surround sound, and it doubles as a Matter hub and Thread border router.
The Apple HomePod mini 2 is the compact Apple option. It works as a home hub, and four of them can form a surround system with the new Apple TV 4K. Apple says Siri AI comes to it in a future software update.
The Apple HomePod (2nd generation) is the room-filling one. Apple says it uses its microphones to sense its position in the room and tune its sound, has a built-in temperature and humidity sensor, and can listen for smoke and carbon monoxide alarms and notify your iPhone.
Your TV as an assistant
For a living room, the television may be the best screen you have. The Apple TV 4K (2026) has three far-field microphones, so you can talk to Siri without the remote, and Apple says it acts as a home hub with built-in Wi-Fi and Thread. With a compatible doorbell, notifications appear on the TV, and you can see and speak to visitors without getting up.
Side by side
| Device | Assistant | Screen | Home hub |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple HomeView | Siri AI (beta) | 7-inch | Yes |
| Google Nest Hub Max | Google ("Hey Google") | 10-inch | Yes, with Thread |
| Google Home Speaker | Gemini for Home | None | Yes, with Thread |
| Apple HomePod mini 2 | Siri (Siri AI in a future update) | None | Yes |
| Apple HomePod (2nd generation) | Siri | None | Yes, with Thread |
| Apple TV 4K (2026) | Siri AI (beta) | Your TV | Yes, with Thread |
Privacy, in practice
Every device here listens for a wake word, and the ones with cameras can see. Each maker offers ways to limit that. Google's speaker has a physical mic mute switch. Apple says HomePod links Siri requests to a random identifier rather than your Apple Account, and that its new devices can handle Siri requests on the device or on its Private Cloud Compute. Put displays with cameras where a camera makes sense, such as the kitchen rather than the bedroom, and review the voice history settings in each app once you are set up.
How to choose
- Follow your phones. An iPhone household will get the most from Siri and Apple Home; an Android household from Google Home.
- One display, several speakers. A screen in the kitchen or hallway, speakers in the other rooms, is the balance most homes settle on.
- Make sure one device is a hub. It is what keeps automations and remote control working.
- Think about sound. If music matters, our guide to building a multi-room system covers how speakers play together.
Browse every display, speaker and hub in our smart home collection.