Tablet or laptop: which should you carry?

|Marcus Chen
A traveller works on a silver MacBook Pro in an airport lounge, suitcases beside her and an aircraft outside the window

A good tablet with a keyboard case can now do much of what a laptop does, and a 2-in-1 can be both at once. That makes the old question harder, not easier: if you are going to carry one device, which kind should it be?

The honest answer depends less on the hardware than on your day. Start with what you do most, where you do it, and what software you cannot do without. Then the choice tends to make itself.

Three kinds of device

  • A tablet with a keyboard case, such as an iPad Pro with Magic Keyboard. A touchscreen first, which becomes a laptop when you attach the keyboard and a slate when you take it off.
  • A Windows 2-in-1, such as Surface Pro. A full Windows computer in tablet form, with a kickstand behind it and a keyboard that clips to the front.
  • A laptop, such as a MacBook. A keyboard, trackpad and screen in a fixed hinge, built to sit on a desk or a lap.

The case for a tablet

The iPad Pro 11-inch (M5) shows what a tablet does well. It weighs 444 g in its Wi-Fi version and is 5.3 mm thin, so on its own it disappears into a bag. Its Ultra Retina XDR tandem OLED display, with ProMotion up to 120 Hz, is among the best screens you can carry, and Apple rates it at up to 10 hours of web browsing or video on Wi-Fi.

A tablet earns its place if much of your day is reading, reviewing, annotating, sketching or watching, with writing in between. You can hold it like a book on a train, hand it across a table in a meeting, and mark up a document with Apple Pencil Pro. Cellular models put 5G in the device itself, so you are not hunting for Wi-Fi or tethering to your phone.

If you want a larger canvas, the iPad Pro 13-inch (M5) offers the same chip and display technology at 13 inches and 579 g. Both work with the Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro (M5), and both have a Thunderbolt / USB 4 port for fast drives and external displays.

A man in a trench coat reads on an iPad Pro held in one hand in the back seat of a car, soft window light

Where a tablet asks for compromise

  • Software. iPadOS runs apps from the App Store. If your work depends on a particular desktop application, plug-in or company tool, check that an iPad version exists and does what you need before you leave the laptop at home.
  • The lap. A keyboard case on a desk is excellent; on your knees, a laptop's fixed hinge and wider base are steadier.
  • The total weight. A tablet is light alone, but the keyboard adds to it. Weigh the combination, not the tablet, against a laptop.

The 2-in-1 middle ground

A Surface Pro answers the software question by running full Windows 11, so your desktop applications come with you. The Surface Pro 13-inch (11th Edition) has a 13-inch 3:2 PixelSense Flow touchscreen, OLED or LCD, up to 120 Hz, and two USB4 ports. Microsoft rates the Wi-Fi models at up to 14 hours of local video playback and up to 10 hours of active web use, and offers 5G models for working away from Wi-Fi. Its storage is a removable SSD.

The Surface Pro 12-inch (1st Edition) is the compact version: a 12-inch display, 686 g without the keyboard, and Microsoft's rating of up to 16 hours of local video playback and up to 12 hours of active web use. The Slim Pen stores and charges on its back.

Both stand on a 165-degree kickstand, which is excellent on a train table or a desk and less so on your lap, where the kickstand needs depth to rest on. Keyboards and pens are sold separately, so include them in your plans. Both run on Snapdragon X chips, which are Arm-based; most Windows software runs well, but if you rely on specialist programs or older hardware drivers, confirm they are supported first.

A young creative in headphones works on an iPad Pro docked on a Magic Keyboard at a long wooden table, other people with iPads and phones around them

The case for a laptop

A laptop wins when your day is long sessions of typing, spreadsheets, coding, or editing with many windows open, and when you often work with the device on your lap. The keyboard is always there, the screen sits at a fixed, comfortable height, and the battery and cooling have more room.

The 14-inch MacBook Pro with M5 is a good example of how far that goes. It pairs a 14-inch Liquid Retina XDR display with the M5 chip and macOS Tahoe, and Apple rates its battery at up to 24 hours. If a laptop is your direction, our guide to MacBook Air or MacBook Pro covers the Mac range in detail.

Questions that settle it

If this sounds like you... Consider
You read, annotate, draw or present more than you type A tablet with a pencil, and a keyboard for occasional writing
You need Windows desktop software but want tablet freedom A Surface Pro
You type for hours, often on your lap A laptop
You want the lightest thing to carry for travel and films A tablet, with or without a keyboard
Your work runs on one specific application Whatever runs it best; check first

Two devices, used well

Many people end up with a laptop at the desk and a tablet for everything else, and that is a perfectly sensible answer. If you go this way, let each do what it is best at rather than buying two of the same. A modest laptop and a smaller tablet often serve better than one expensive device asked to do everything.

A Surface Pro in Sapphire standing on its kickstand with its keyboard, behind a Surface Laptop in matching blue, both screens showing the Windows bloom, on a pale blue background

Before you decide

  • Write down the three things you do most on a typical workday, and the one application you could not do without.
  • Price the whole kit: tablet or 2-in-1 plus keyboard and pen, against the laptop alone.
  • Check ports: you may need a USB-C hub or adapter for older drives and displays, whichever you choose.
  • Think about your bag. Weigh what you will actually carry, including chargers.

You can compare every tablet and 2-in-1 we carry in our tablets collection.